Reese’s Inside Out Peanut Butter Cups

Posted on by Ashley Bischoff

I heard about Reese’s Inside-Out Peanut Butter Cups from Supermarket Guru’s New Products page. As you might expect, they’re peanut butter cups, except that the peanut butter bit is on the outside and the chocolate is in the center. But, the review on Supermarket Guru wasn’t so positive:

Here’s what Julie Messerer from Hoquiam, Washington had to say about this product. “The peanut butter is on the outside with a chocolate filling inside. Reese’s is my favorite candy bar (my husband’s, too), and we both agree that it’s too much peanut butter flavoring. We couldn’t taste any chocolate! We’ll stick with the original Reese’s. […] ”

So, on account of the peanut-butteryness, they consider it a “Miss”. But, come on, how could any product have too much peanut butter? Of course, with as much sugar as they probably have, I don’t think I’ll be buying any except perhaps for Halloween festivities (if they last that long). I, for one, welcome our new peanut butter overlords.

16 thoughts on “Reese’s Inside Out Peanut Butter Cups”

  2. inside out peanut butter cups by reese’s are the best! i love regular peanut butter cups, but always eat the chocolate tops first, so i can get enough peanut butter flavoring on my taste buds…having tried the inside out cups this halloween, i have no interest in going back to regular! you get the full flavor of the peanut butter with some chocolate taste! As for Julie Messerer of Hoquiam, WA, all i have to say is you have a valid argument if they were called chocolate cups! as far as i’m concerned, they’ve been making them the wrong way until now!
    bmc

  3. Reeses inside out was so good. I liked even better than the original one. It kinda’ of reminded me of the peanut butter patty girlscout cookies. Hope they keep it out or come out with it more often.

  4. Just wanted to comment on this product. I picked a package up by mistake. But now that I’ve tasted the I enjoyed them, I now want to find them again. Can’t find them. Where in the world are they and why can’t I find any more of them. Are they not in production anymore. I don’t think the are a production mistake. They are delicious!!!. Glad I bought them thinking they were the original. Any help in locating the store/s they are available in will be apopreciated.

  6. Someone where I work gave me one of these candies. I loved it and have been trying to find a source. I have looked at Safeway, Albertson’s, King Sooper, Walmart and many convenience stores, all to no avail. I even called a local candy distributor and they didn’t have any. Where can I get more?

  7. I agree!!!!!! I’m still looking for them. They are so good. I’m not a big candy freak, but when I find one that taste good I stick to it. I am trying to find some but I can’t. It appears that you can still oreder them online at the Candy store but they charge tooo much and you have to pay for shipping and handeling. Please if any one knows of a place here in California, please let me know. They really need to bring this candy back. They brought white chocolate back by popular demand, but how about these!!!!!!!!!!!

  8. They are still around! (1 year since this page was created) I personally like these better than the originals because I like the peanut butter more than the chocolate. I just grabbed a couple bags from the store since they are hard to find!

  12. Inside out peautbutter cups are the best chocolates on earth. They sold then during Halloween but now I can’t find them in stores any where

  14. We really enjoyed this cup but can not find them any more. We would like to know if there is any place to buy them. thanks

  15. OMG I been looking for the inside out cup everywhere. This halloween I was hoping they would bring it back,but they didn’t! Does anyone know if they will ever package them again?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.